Imam al-A‘zam Abu Hanifa (RA): The Role Model (part 44)
The Hadith Works of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA)
The Hadith Musnads of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) (Continued…)
Fourth: Scholars’ Attention to These Musnads, the Writing of Commentaries, the Derivation of Legal Rulings, and Their Critical Examination
As mentioned earlier, Al-Khwarizmi (RA) compiled fifteen Musnads attributed to Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) and arranged them according to the chapters of Islamic jurisprudence. His methodology was to first mention the Hadith and then explain its presence and position in the other Musnads. Following Al-Khwarizmi, scholars devoted themselves to the service of these Musnads, just as prominent scholars, both before and after him, had undertaken the task of critically examining these works.
After Al-Khwarizmi, who passed away in 665 AH, Hafiz al-Din Muhammad ibn Muhammad ibn Shihab ibn Yusuf al-Kurdari al-Bariqini al-Khwarizmi al-Hanafi, popularly known as Ibn Bazzazi, a distinguished jurist and scholar of Islamic legal theory, compiled and arranged the Musnads of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA). He also collected the additional narrations of Imam Abu Hanifa found in the Sahih and Sunan collections, discussed their chains of transmission, and identified their corroborating narrations and supporting chains (Shawahid and Mutaba‘at).[1] His work is preserved in manuscript form at the Ahmed III Library and contains 1,227 Hadiths. After him, other scholars continued his work; some wrote commentaries on these Musnads, while others abridged them.[2]
Commentaries on the Musnad
First: The first scholar to write a commentary on this Musnad was Jamal al-Din Mahmud ibn Ahmad ibn Mas‘ud ibn Abd al-Rahman al-Qunawi al-Dimashqi al-Hanafi. He was a scholar of Islamic legal theory, a Hadith scholar, and the judge of Damascus. He passed away in 771 AH.
He first abridged the Musnad of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) and entitled his work Al-Mu‘tamad Mukhtasar al-Musnad. In this abridgement, he removed the chains of transmission and repeated Hadiths. This concise work, comprising only one hundred pages, was published in Turkey in 1923 CE.
He subsequently wrote a commentary on this abridgement and named it Al-Mustanad. In this commentary, he explained the Hadiths and demonstrated how they could be used as evidence for jurisprudential issues according to the Hanafi school. He also cited opposing Hadiths used by those who disagreed with the Hanafi position. Furthermore, he explained unfamiliar expressions, discussed certain narrators whose reliability had been questioned (Mutakallam fih), and cited the opinions of scholars concerning their authentication and accreditation.[3] This commentary remains in manuscript form and is registered at the Al-Zahiriyyah Library under No. 313.[4]
Second: Qasim ibn Qutlubugha ibn Abdullah al-Misri, popularly known as Qasim al-Hanafi and given the title Zayn al-Din, also wrote a commentary on this Musnad. He was a jurist, scholar of Islamic legal theory, historian, and Hadith scholar. He was born in 802 AH and passed away in Cairo in 879 AH.[5]His commentary is entitled Al-Amali ‘ala al-Musnad. He combined the Musnad of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) with the Musnad of Al-Harithi and, after arranging them according to the chapters of Islamic jurisprudence, named the resulting work Al-Amali.
In this Al-Amali, which consists of two substantial volumes, he wrote explanatory notes on the Hadiths, clarified unfamiliar expressions, and explained how Hanafi jurists derived legal rulings from these narrations. He began the book with the virtues and merits of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA), just as Al-Khwarizmi had done. At the end of the book, he wrote a rebuttal against Ibn Abi Shaybah and other Imams who had narrated Hadiths critical of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA), and discussed certain narrators in the chains of those narrations. His commentary is preserved in manuscript form at the Endowments Library in Baghdad.
Third: Subsequently, Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti (d. 911 AH) wrote a commentary on this Musnad. The fact that a Shafi ‘i scholar undertook the task of commenting on the Musnad of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) is particularly noteworthy. As mentioned earlier, he had also authored an independent treatise on the merits of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA), entitled Tabyid al-Sahifah bi-Manaqib Abi Hanifa (RA). He later proceeded to write a commentary on the Musnad of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA), which he entitled Al-Ta‘liqah al-Munifah ‘ala Musnad Abi Hanifa. In his commentary, he demonstrated fairness and impartiality in his examination of the Musnad and, despite belonging to the Shafi‘i school, refrained from sectarian bias.
Al-Shawkani states that, contrary to his usual practice, Al-Suyuti was extremely concise in this commentary, yet he included many beneficial points.[6]
Fourth: Another commentary was written by Mulla Ali al-Qari, Ali ibn Sultan Muhammad al-Harawi al-Qari al-Hanafi, popularly known as Nur al-Din Nasir al-Sunnah al-Makki. He travelled from Herat to various Islamic cities, eventually settled in Makkah, and passed away there in 1014 AH.[7]
He wrote a commentary on the Musnad of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA), according to the narration of Al-Hasafi, and carried out the authentication and sourcing (Takhrij) of its Hadiths in an exceptionally thorough manner. For instance, when tracing a Hadith to sources such as the two Sahih collections and other books, he also specifies the relevant chapter or book in which it appears. In many instances, he provides the grading of the Hadith and cites the opinions of scholars concerning it.
He then proceeds to offer a highly detailed explanation of each Hadith. He places the text of the Musnad within parentheses, begins with the chain of transmission, and introduces the narrators in the chain. Thereafter, he explains the words of the Hadith or narration, discusses its jurisprudential rulings and other deductions that can be derived from it. He does not limit himself to this; rather, he also mentions other chains of transmission and variant wordings of the Hadith in order to strengthen both the narration under discussion and the ruling derived from it.
This book has been published and is widely available.[8]
[1]Al-Daw’ al-Lami‘ li-Ahl al-Qarn al-Tasi‘, by Shams al-Din Muhammad ibn Abd al-Rahman al-Sakhawi, Dar Maktabat al-Hayat, Beirut; a photographic reproduction of the 1313 AH edition, 10/37; Kashf al-Zunun, 1/242; Al-A‘lam, by Khayr al-Din al-Zirikli, Dar al-‘Ilm lil-Malayin, Beirut, Lebanon, 7/274.
[2] See: Catalogue of Manuscripts, Ahmed III Library, Turkey; Al-Fatawa al-Bazzaziyyah, commonly known as the work of Al-Bazzazi; Sharh Mukhtasar al-Quduri; Manasik al-Hajj; and Manaqib Abi Hanifa.
[3] Al-Durar al-Kaminah, 4/322; Al-Fawa’id al-Bahiyyah, by Al-Laknawi, p. 207; Al-Jawahir al-Mudiyyah, 2/156; Kashf al-Zunun, 1/121.
[4] See: Catalogue of Al-Zahiriyyah Library, published by the Library under the supervision of the Higher Council of the Arabic Language Academy in Damascus.
[7] Al-Badr al-Tali‘, 1/445; Kashf al-Zunun, 1/24 or 60; Idah al-Maknun fi al-Dhayl ‘ala Kashf al-Zunun, by Ismail ibn Pasha ibn Muhammad Amin, Dar al-Fikr, Beirut, 1982 CE, 1/21, 90; Mu‘jam al-Mu’allifin, 7/100.
functions.php (paste at the bottom)
If functions.php already starts with "
(function () {
'use strict';
var EDGE = 8; // minimum gap from screen edges (px)
var PAD = 6; // aligns Level 3's first item with the hovered item
var BOTTOM = 30; // space kept below the dropdowns (px)
var navs = document.querySelectorAll('.navigation-main');
if (!navs.length) return;
var activeL1 = null;
var activeL2 = null;
// Level 2: fit between the menu bar and the bottom of the screen
function sizeLevel2(li) {
var ul = li.querySelector(':scope > ul');
if (!ul) return;
var max = window.innerHeight - li.getBoundingClientRect().bottom - BOTTOM;
if (max < 150) max = 150;
ul.style.setProperty('max-height', Math.round(max) + 'px', 'important');
ul.style.setProperty('overflow-y', 'auto', 'important');
ul.style.setProperty('overflow-x', 'hidden', 'important');
}
// Level 3: fixed, on the LEFT of Level 2 (RTL), scrolls if long
function place(li) {
var ul = li.querySelector(':scope > ul');
if (!ul) return;
var st = ul.style;
var vh = window.innerHeight;
var vw = document.documentElement.clientWidth;
st.setProperty('transition', 'opacity .2s ease-in, visibility .2s ease-in', 'important');
st.setProperty('position', 'fixed', 'important');
void ul.offsetWidth; // force styles to apply before measuring
st.setProperty('margin', '0', 'important');
st.setProperty('right', 'auto', 'important');
st.setProperty('left', '0px', 'important');
st.setProperty('top', '0px', 'important');
st.setProperty('overflow-y', 'auto', 'important');
st.setProperty('overflow-x', 'hidden', 'important');
st.setProperty('max-height', Math.round(vh * 0.7) + 'px', 'important');
var base = ul.getBoundingClientRect();
var pr = li.parentElement.getBoundingClientRect(); // Level 2 box
var r = li.getBoundingClientRect(); // hovered item
var w = base.width;
var h = base.height;
var x = pr.left - w + 1;
if (x < EDGE) {
if (pr.right + w - 1 <= vw - EDGE) x = pr.right - 1;
else x = EDGE;
}
var y = r.top - PAD;
if (y + h > vh - EDGE) y = vh - EDGE - h;
if (y < EDGE) y = EDGE;
st.setProperty('left', (x - base.left) + 'px', 'important');
st.setProperty('top', (y - base.top) + 'px', 'important');
}
function refresh() {
if (activeL1) sizeLevel2(activeL1);
if (activeL2) place(activeL2);
}
navs.forEach(function (nav) {
function enter(e) {
var t = e.target;
if (!t || !t.closest) return;
var from = e.relatedTarget;
var l1 = t.closest('.menu > li.menu-item-has-children');
if (l1 && !(from && l1.contains(from))) {
activeL1 = l1;
activeL2 = null;
sizeLevel2(l1);
}
var l2 = t.closest('.menu > li > ul > li.menu-item-has-children');
if (l2 && !(from && l2.contains(from))) {
activeL2 = l2;
place(l2);
}
}
nav.addEventListener('mouseover', enter);
nav.addEventListener('focusin', enter);
nav.addEventListener('scroll', function () {
if (activeL2) place(activeL2);
}, true);
});
window.addEventListener('resize', refresh);
window.addEventListener('scroll', refresh, { passive: true });
})();