The Structural Differences Between Men and Women: Shared Humanity
While there are structural differences between men and women, there is no difference in their humanity. A woman is not different from a man in terms of humanity; rather, the differences lie in their physical composition. These physical differences have resulted in different roles and responsibilities.
Genetic and anthropological research demonstrates that women and men have distinct biological compositions. This difference is evident from the very first moments of fertilization (the sperm and egg) and continues through all stages of embryonic development. Men and women differ at every stage. This difference is reflected in every cell of their bodies, preparing each for specific tasks.
Dr. Alexis Karil, who has witnessed the role of women in contemporary society and the challenges they face, states: “The fact is that women are very different from men. Every cell of a woman’s body has its own structure, and this structure exists in all the organs of her body, especially in her nervous system. It should not be forgotten that genetic laws, like other principles, cannot be compromised, and human desires cannot be altered. They must be accepted as they are. Therefore, women should cultivate their competencies according to their intrinsic nature, avoiding blind imitation of men and embracing their unique feminine duties.”
Aristotle, a student of Plato, holds that the talents of men and women differ significantly. The duties assigned to each by the law of creation and the rights demanded of them are fundamentally different in many aspects.
Professor Rick, a well-known American psychologist with extensive research on men and women, states: “A man’s world is entirely different from a woman’s world. If a woman cannot think like a man, it is because their bodies are inherently different. Additionally, the feelings of these two genders will never be identical, nor will they respond in the same manner to events. Based on their inherent sexual roles, men and women behave differently and operate in distinct orbits, much like two stars. They can understand each other and complement one another, but they never become one. This is the reason men and women can live together, fall in love, and appreciate each other’s traits and qualities.”
Ms. Cleod Elson, a female psychologist, states: “My greatest interest lies in studying the psyche of men. Recently, I was tasked with researching the psychological factors affecting both men and women. Ultimately, I concluded that women are more influenced by emotions, while men are guided by reason. Men tend to think more practically, judge more effectively, organize efficiently, and lead decisively. Regardless of how much women may wish to challenge this reality, it remains steadfast, suggesting they often require male oversight in their lives.”
Research has evidenced developmental differences between men and women, supported by scientific and psychological studies. These differences are permanent and common across similar demographics, leading to legal and legislative distinctions.
This principle underpins the division of responsibilities and duties between men and women in Islam, aligning with their inherent compositions and the realities of social and marital life. One key issue regarding women’s lives is family management and guardianship, which we will explore further in upcoming discussions.